Most Black Friday emails are written for strangers. They shout a percentage, they assume nobody has heard of you, and they go to everyone on the list at once. The best data I have seen on who actually buys during Black Friday week says those emails are aimed at the wrong reader. The buyers who matter most have had your product for months, they know what it does, and they have been waiting for a reason to pay.

So my take for this Friday is simple: make one honest, time-boxed offer on your annual plan, and send it first to the people who already know you.

What the RevenueCat data shows

On 27 October 2026, RevenueCat (the subscription billing platform used by a lot of mobile apps) published an analysis of 4,964 subscription apps across the 2025–26 holiday season, written by Margarita Loktionova. Each app was measured against its own baseline from 15 September to 12 October 2025, so a big app and a small app are compared with themselves, not with each other. Of those apps, 421 ran a promotion that RevenueCat could detect during Black Friday week (24 November to 1 December 2025).

The headline numbers are worth reading slowly.

Two more findings matter, because they are the cost and the alternative. Over the next six months, the median app earned 8% less revenue per buyer from its Black Friday cohort. But there were more buyers, so a cohort acquired on an average sale day generated 12% more revenue over six months, and 60% of apps came out ahead overall. Across the wider window from 10 November to 14 December, the median app with a promotion finished 1% below its baseline, against 12% below for apps without one. Then, in apps that had run a Black Friday promotion, January buyers generated 10% more six-month revenue per customer than Black Friday buyers.

Now the caveats, in RevenueCat's own words. "The comparisons show associations, not direct proof that promotions cause growth." Its detection relies mostly on purchases, so "offers with few or no sales can go undetected", which means the failed promotions are probably under-counted. The results describe the median app, the install-timing split uses an average, and first annual renewals fall outside the six-month follow-up, so nobody yet knows how many of those discounted annual buyers will renew at full price. These are mobile apps, too, and a SaaS tool or a paid newsletter will not behave identically.

Even with those limits, I think the shape of the result is clear enough to act on. Black Friday offers mostly convert people who were already halfway there, and those people lean towards a year, not a month.

Why it works, and who it suits

An annual plan asks for a bigger decision than a monthly one. A stranger has no reason to make that decision on day one. Someone who has used your free tier since August, or trialled you in the summer and drifted off, already knows whether the product earns its place. What they lack is a nudge with a date on it, and Black Friday supplies that nudge for free, because everybody expects offers this week.

For you, a discounted annual sale is worth more than it looks. You get twelve months of cash up front, you skip eleven chances to churn, and you get a year to make the product part of the customer's routine. The refund figure suggests the buyers feel it was a considered choice rather than an impulse.

This suits three kinds of business:

  • Subscription apps with a free tier or a trial, which is exactly the sample RevenueCat measured.

  • Small SaaS products with monthly and annual plans and a base of free or lapsed accounts.

  • Membership and newsletter creators with a paid tier, where the free list is the long-tenure audience.

It suits you less if you have no annual plan and no time to make one properly, if your free users are almost all from the last few weeks, or if a big product change is coming in January that might make a year-long commitment feel like a bait and switch.

What you need

  • A list you can segment by signup or install date, last activity and past payment status. An export from your database or analytics tool into a spreadsheet is enough.

  • Your existing email tool, able to send to segments and schedule sends. Newsletter creators can do all of this inside their newsletter platform.

  • A billing system that supports an expiring discount on the first payment only. In Stripe, a coupon's duration defaults to "once", "which applies only to the first invoice", and you can set a "redeem_by" date so it stops working when the sale ends. On a yearly subscription that means the discount covers year one and the renewal goes back to list price on its own.

  • Editing access to your pricing page for a banner and a crossed-out price.

  • Time: my estimate is one working day to segment, write and schedule, plus an hour a day during the sale to watch the numbers.

  • Cost: nothing extra if you already pay for these tools. What you actually pay for is the discount, and the worked example below puts a number on it.

Step by step

1. Segment by tenure and intent (Monday or Tuesday)

Pull every account that is not currently on a paid annual plan and sort it into four groups. Keep it to four, because each group gets its own copy.

  1. Warm and long-tenure: free users or trialists who signed up more than three months ago and were active in the last 60 days. RevenueCat's data points at this group, so it gets the earliest and most personal email.

  2. Dormant and long-tenure: signed up more than three months ago, no activity in the last 60 days. They know you but have drifted.

  3. Recent: signed up in the last three months. Include them in the main send, but do not lead with them.

  4. Lapsed subscribers: people who paid and then cancelled. They get a win-back version of the email, not the generic one.

Current monthly subscribers are a fifth audience. Don't hide the sale from them, because they will see the banner anyway. Offer them the same discounted annual plan as a switch, with the unused part of their month credited, so the people already paying you are not the ones who get the worst deal.

2. Choose the discount and make it annual-only

Put the discount on the annual plan only, for the first year only. Leave the monthly price alone. That keeps the offer simple, it pushes buyers towards the plan they already prefer this week, and it stops you training monthly customers to expect a cheaper month every November.

Depth is a judgement call, and RevenueCat's data gives you context rather than an answer. Nearly three in four Black Friday percentage discounts on the paywalls it studied were 50% or more, yet the article itself says a deep cut "isn't always needed". My decision rule is to work out what an average monthly subscriber pays you before they cancel (monthly price multiplied by the average number of months they stay), and set the discounted first-year price at or above that figure. Then a Black Friday annual buyer is worth at least as much to you as a normal monthly buyer, even if they never renew. If your average monthly subscriber stays five months at $10, any first-year price of $50 or more passes.

Use one price for everyone, and show it as a price rather than only as a percentage: "$60 for your first year (normally $96)". People can check a price. A percentage invites arithmetic.

3. Set the deadline and the honest renewal terms

Run the offer from Friday 27 November to the end of Cyber Monday, 30 November 2026, and name the hour and time zone ("ends 11:59pm [your time zone], Monday 30 November"). Set the coupon's expiry to match, so the deadline is real in your billing system as well as in the email.

The crossed-out price must be one you genuinely charge. In the US, the FTC's pricing guides say a former price is a legitimate basis for a comparison when it is "the actual, bona fide price at which the article was offered to the public on a regular basis" for "a reasonably substantial period of time". Other countries have similar rules. If you raised your list price last week to make the discount look bigger, don't run this.

Then state the renewal price at the point of purchase, in plain words, next to the buy button and in the receipt: "Renews at $96 a year on 27 November 2027 unless you cancel. We'll email you two weeks before." Then put that reminder in your calendar or automation now, while you remember.

4. Write and schedule the email sequence

Four sends at most for any one person, and fewer for anyone who has already bought. Suppress buyers from every later send within minutes of their purchase, because a "last chance" email to someone who paid yesterday reads as careless.

Email 1, Tuesday 24 November, warm long-tenure segment only (early access).

❝

Subject: You've used [Product] since [month]. A year of it for $60, this week only

Hi [first name],

You've been using [Product] for [N] months on the free plan, mostly for [their most-used feature]. This week only, you can get a full year of [Paid plan] for $60 instead of $96. That's $5 a month for [two or three paid features they keep hitting limits on].

You're getting this a few days before everyone else, because you're one of the people who uses [Product] most. The offer ends at 11:59pm [your time zone] on Monday 30 November.

[Get a year for $60]

It renews at $96 a year unless you cancel, and I'll email you two weeks before it does.

The reference to their own use matters most in that email. RevenueCat's practical advice is to target existing free users with a paywall built around the paid features they're missing, and an email can do the same thing with one merge field.

Email 2, Friday 27 November, all segments (launch). Same offer, shorter copy. For the dormant group, lead with what has changed since they last logged in. For lapsed subscribers, use the win-back version:

❝

Subject: Come back to [Product] for $60 a year

Hi [first name],

You were a [Product] subscriber until [month]. Since then we've added [one or two concrete changes, ideally the thing they asked for or cancelled over]. Until Monday, you can come back on the annual plan for $60 for your first year (normally $96).

[Rejoin for $60]

Renews at $96 a year unless you cancel. Offer ends 11:59pm [your time zone], Monday 30 November.

Email 3, Saturday 28 November, non-openers of email 2 only. A resend with a different subject line, such as "A year of [Product] for $5 a month". Nothing else changes.

Email 4, Monday 30 November, morning, everyone who opened or clicked but did not buy. A short last-day note that names the hour it ends. No countdown theatrics. RevenueCat found about a third of Black Friday paywalls used limited-time wording and one in five added a countdown, and it warns that too much pressure can feel pushy, so test the nudge rather than assume it.

5. Put the offer on the pricing page

Add a slim banner above the plans: "Black Friday: the annual plan is $60 for your first year (normally $96). Ends 11:59pm [your time zone], Monday 30 November." On the annual card, show the crossed-out $96, the $60, and the renewal line in small but readable type. Make the annual card the default selection for the four days, and remove the banner, the coupon and the default by Tuesday morning. If the offer quietly carries on into December, nobody believes your next deadline.

If you also have an in-product paywall, match the wording exactly. A different price in the email and on the page will fill your support inbox.

6. Hold some people back so you can measure it

Randomly hold back about 10% of the warm long-tenure segment from every email (they can still find the pricing-page banner). Compare purchase rates between the two groups after Cyber Monday. That gap is your best estimate of what the emails added, as opposed to what would have happened anyway. If you have not run one before, the DIY holdout test walks through the set-up.

A worked example (illustrative maths, not real results)

Every number in this section is invented to show the arithmetic. Swap in your own.

Imagine an app at $10 a month or $96 a year, with 5,000 free accounts and 400 lapsed subscribers. The average monthly subscriber stays five months, so a monthly buyer is worth about $50. The Black Friday offer is $60 for the first year, which clears that $50 floor.

  • Warm long-tenure: 1,800 accounts. Assume 3% buy, so 54 buyers.

  • Dormant long-tenure: 1,200 accounts. Assume 0.75% buy, so 9 buyers.

  • Recent: 2,000 accounts. Assume 1% buy, so 20 buyers.

  • Lapsed subscribers: 400. Assume 6% come back, so 24 buyers.

That gives 107 annual buyers at $60, or $6,420 collected up front. Now take off the cost of the discount to people who would have bought anyway. Say your holdout suggests 25 of the 107 would have bought the annual plan at full price that week. Each of them paid $36 less than they would have, so the discount cost you 25 × $36 = $900. The remaining 82 buyers are extra, worth 82 × $60 = $4,920. Net of the giveaway, the offer added about $4,020 in its first year.

Compare that with the same 82 people buying monthly at full price and staying the average five months: 82 × $50 = $4,100. The two are close, which is what the floor is for. The annual sale breaks even on year one and then has a chance to renew at $96. If, say, 40% of the 107 renewed next November, that would be 43 renewals × $96 = $4,128 in year two. Treat that 40% as a guess. RevenueCat's follow-up stops before first renewals, so nothing in its data tells you what the renewal rate will be.

The example also shows where the money sits. The warm long-tenure group produces half the buyers from about a third of the list, which matches the direction of RevenueCat's finding. If you only have time for one well-written email, write it for them.

What to watch

  • New paying customers per day against your own baseline. Use your September–October daily average, as RevenueCat did, not last week.

  • Annual share of new payers. RevenueCat's median moved from 41% to 49%. If yours does not move, the offer or the page is not making the annual plan obvious enough.

  • Buyers by segment and tenure. If most buyers are brand-new signups, you are selling to deal-hunters, and your renewal rate next year will probably show it.

  • Holdout gap in the warm segment, as described above.

  • 30-day refund rate. RevenueCat's annual buyers fell to 2.7%. A spike above your normal rate suggests the copy oversold something.

  • Unsubscribes and spam complaints per send. Four emails in a week is a lot for a free list. If one send's unsubscribe rate is several times your normal rate, cut the next one.

  • Six-month revenue per buyer, checked in late May 2027, against your normal cohort. Expect it to be lower. RevenueCat's median was 8% lower.

  • First renewal rate in late November 2027. That number decides whether this worked.

Tests worth running

Most small lists are too small for a clean A/B test on purchase rate, so pick one test and accept that it gives you direction, not proof. In order of usefulness, I'd test these:

  1. Holdout versus email in the warm segment, because it tells you whether the campaign mattered at all.

  2. Price-led versus percentage-led subject lines ("A year for $60" against "38% off annual"), measured on clicks, which you will have enough of.

  3. Early access versus no early access for the warm segment, to see whether the Tuesday send pulls purchases forward or adds to them.

  4. Annual card as default versus monthly card as default on the pricing page, measured on annual share of new payers.

Pitfalls

Training customers to wait. RevenueCat's apps without an offer got 16% fewer new payers during Black Friday week, which suggests some buyers now hold off until a sale. Don't add to it with a December sale, a Christmas sale and a New Year sale. RevenueCat found Christmas weak for the median app even with a promotion (11% below baseline), and apps that ran offers at both Black Friday and Christmas were still 7% below at Christmas. One clean offer, then full price.

Lower revenue per buyer. The 8% drop in the median app is what the extra buyers cost. The floor rule in step 2 is there so that the drop doesn't turn into a loss for you.

Renewal shock. Someone who paid $60 and gets charged $96 without warning will often ask for a refund and tell people about it. The renewal line on the page, in the receipt and in a reminder email two weeks before the renewal date is what prevents that. If you sell through the app stores, check how their offer tools describe the renewal price, and repeat it in your own words.

Fake reference prices. A crossed-out price you never charged is a legal risk in many countries and a trust problem everywhere.

Punishing your current payers. If a monthly subscriber of two years can't get the deal a free user gets, you've told your best customers they come last. Offer them the switch.

Lifetime deals by accident. RevenueCat saw lifetime options on 35–38% of Black Friday and New Year paywalls, against 17% the rest of the year. If you add one, its advice is to price it with annual subscribers in mind, since lifetime buyers never renew. I would leave lifetime out of a first attempt.

Variations

Prepaid credits for usage-based products. If you charge per task, per minute or per credit rather than per month, the equivalent offer is a credit pack: pay $300 now and get $400 of usage that lasts twelve months. Send it to long-tenure free and pay-as-you-go users, apply the same floor logic (the pack should be worth at least what an average user spends with you in that period), and state clearly when unused credit expires.

"Lock in this price". If you are genuinely raising prices in the new year, Black Friday is a fair moment to say so and let people commit to a year at today's price. The deadline then has a real reason behind it. Only use this if the rise is decided and dated.

Win-back for lapsed subscribers. RevenueCat's 9% finding suggests that for some apps, past subscribers respond strongly to an offer. Pair the email with whatever you learned when they cancelled. If you collect cancellation reasons, a reason-matched cancel flow gives you the sentence to lead with.

Paid newsletter tiers. For creators, the same structure works on an annual paid subscription: free subscribers who have opened most issues for three months or more are the warm long-tenure group, and the offer is the first year of the paid tier at a lower price, renewing at the normal annual rate.

A smaller January offer. In apps that ran a Black Friday promotion, January buyers were worth 10% more over six months, and new payers were up 14% over New Year and January for apps with offers. RevenueCat cautions that this does not show New Year offers improve revenue, and suggests a smaller discount may be enough when people are buying anyway. Plan a lighter January send to anyone who clicked in November and didn't buy, then compare the two cohorts. Once they are paying, the 30-day upsell window covers what to offer them next.

Your checklist for this week

  1. Monday: export accounts with signup date, last activity and payment status; build the four segments plus current monthly payers; pick a 10% holdout from the warm group.

  2. Monday: calculate your floor (monthly price × average months retained) and set a first-year annual price at or above it.

  3. Tuesday morning: create the first-invoice-only coupon with an expiry of 11:59pm on 30 November; test a purchase end to end, including the receipt's renewal line.

  4. Tuesday: send the early-access email to the warm long-tenure segment.

  5. Thursday: build the pricing-page banner and annual card change, ready to go live on Friday morning.

  6. Friday 27 November: launch to all segments, with the win-back version for lapsed subscribers and the switch offer for monthly payers.

  7. Saturday: resend to non-openers. Monday: last-day email to openers and clickers who didn't buy.

  8. Tuesday 1 December: remove the banner and coupon, compare holdout and email groups, and schedule renewal reminders for November 2027.

If you only manage the first email to the warm segment and an honest renewal line, you will have done the part that the data supports most strongly.

Sources