The best time to offer the second thing is while the card is already out, as long as the second thing is something the buyer would want anyway.
Think about the last time you bought a course or joined a paid community. You had already decided. You had typed your card number, maybe hunted for the security code, and your thumb was over the pay button. If a small box had appeared just above that button offering the workbook that goes with the course, for a one-time price, you would have read it properly, because you were paying attention. Ask the same question a week later in an email and you would probably skim past it.
That small box is called an order bump, and this week it reached a lot more creators. On 19 November, Circle (the community and course platform) shipped order bumps in its November release. The release describes it as "a one-click add-on at checkout, like a $29 mini-course on a $50/mo membership." The offer sits above the purchase button, the member adds it with one click, and Circle says "everything is included in the same purchase with no extra steps." It is rolling out now, and Circle says everyone gets access by the end of November.
Circle published no take rates or revenue figures with the launch, so we won't pretend to know how well it performs. What we can do is work through the idea from the buyer's side, put some clearly labelled numbers on it, and show you how to set one up today on Circle and on two other common checkouts.
Why it works
Most of the cost of a sale is getting someone to the point of paying. They have found you, trusted you enough, picked a plan and started typing card details. By the time they reach the pay button, all of that work is done. Adding a second, smaller item at that moment costs the buyer one decision and no new form, no second checkout and no fresh trust. Selling the same item later means doing much of that work again: an email they have to open, a page they have to visit, a card they have to enter.
A post-purchase upsell (an offer shown after payment) gets the same timing benefit, and Circle added those the month before. The difference is position. A bump appears before payment, so it has to be small and obvious enough to decide on in a few seconds. Circle's own help guide puts it plainly: "Keep the order bump closely related to the original purchase and easy to understand. Save offers that need more explanation for the upsell page."
Most people skip over the condition in that opening line. A bump works because it saves the buyer a step they would have taken anyway. If the add-on is something they would have gone looking for in their first week, offering it at checkout is a service. If it is an unrelated product you want to shift, you are asking someone to make a second buying decision at the exact moment they are trying to finish the first, and some of them will abandon both.
Who it's for
This suits you if you sell a membership, course, cohort, event ticket or paid community through a hosted checkout, and you already have (or can make in a day) a smaller companion item. It suits creators with steady checkout volume more than those with a launch once a year, because you need a few hundred checkouts to learn anything. It suits you less if your buyers are companies paying by invoice, where a purchase order fixes the amount in advance, or if your main product is cheap enough that a $29 add-on would cost more than the thing being bought.
The buyer test
Before you build anything, run the add-on through three questions from the buyer's side. Would a new buyer ask for this within their first week? Does it make the main purchase work better or faster, rather than sitting beside it? Can they understand exactly what they get, and that it is a one-time price, from one sentence? If any answer is no, it does not belong above the pay button.
Good candidates usually pass easily. A template pack for a membership about building a business, so the member starts with working files instead of a blank page. The recording of last month's workshop for someone buying a ticket to this month's. A 30-minute starter session on a coaching membership, so the first week has a plan. Weak candidates fail on the first question: a second course on a different topic, merchandise, or a discount on something you sell elsewhere.
What you need
You need one add-on product the buyer test approves, priced as a one-time purchase. You need a checkout that supports bumps natively (Circle, ThriveCart and Stripe Checkout all do; more on each below). You need a sentence of headline copy, a sentence or two of description and, on Circle, a cover image. Time is mostly in making the add-on: if you already have the templates or the recording, setup takes under an hour; if you have to make the asset, budget a day. Circle's release notes don't list a separate charge for bumps, but the add-on is charged in the same payment, so your plan's usual transaction fees apply to it as well.
The maths (a designed model, not results)
Every number in this section is an assumption we chose for illustration. None of it comes from Circle or from any real community. Imagine you run a membership at $50 a month with 200 new checkouts a month, and you add a $29 one-time template pack as a bump.
Assumed take rate | Bumps a month | Extra revenue a month | Average first order | Extra over a year |
|---|---|---|---|---|
5% | 10 | $290 | $51.45 | $3,480 |
10% | 20 | $580 | $52.90 | $6,960 |
15% | 30 | $870 | $54.35 | $10,440 |
Read the middle row this way: at an assumed 10% take rate, the bump adds $580 to the $10,000 that those 200 first payments bring in, a rise of 5.8% in first-month revenue, with no new traffic and no new email. That is useful money for a solo creator, though not life-changing. The figures are before payment fees and refunds, and they assume the bump does not cost you any main sales, which you have to check rather than assume (more on that under metrics).
Two things follow from the model. First, the add-on price matters more than people expect: the same 10% take rate on a $9 add-on brings in $180 a month, which may not be worth the extra line on your checkout. Second, at 200 checkouts a month, 10% is 20 people, so one good or bad week can swing the rate a lot. Give any test at least two months before you decide.
You will find order-bump take-rate figures on the blogs of checkout vendors such as ThriveCart and SamCart. Those are each vendor's own unaudited figures, published by companies that sell the feature, so we have left them out of this model.
Step by step
Pick the add-on with the buyer test. Write down the one thing new buyers most often ask for in their first week. If you have support messages or a community, search them for "do you have" and "where can I find". That list usually names your bump for you.
Make it deliverable without you. The buyer should get the add-on automatically after payment. A download, a course module or a recording link works. A starter session needs a booking link in the confirmation email, not a manual follow-up.
Set a one-time price. Price it so that it feels small next to the main purchase. As a starting rule of thumb (our estimate, not a benchmark), aim for somewhere between a third and two thirds of the first payment, so $29 on a $50 membership sits comfortably. Label it "one-time" in the copy so nobody thinks they are adding a second subscription.
Set it up on Circle. According to Circle's guide, you first create the add-on as its own one-time purchase paywall. Then go to Payments, then Paywalls, open the paywall you want to add it to and choose Edit, and click the Order bump tab. Select Create bump, choose the add-on's paywall and price, and add a title, an optional description and a cover image. You can add an optional strikethrough price, and up to three bumps per paywall. Save, then buy it yourself with a test or a coupon to see exactly what the member sees.
Or set it up on Stripe Checkout or ThriveCart. On Stripe Checkout, cross-sells are configured in the Dashboard on the main product's page, in the Cross-sells section; the add-on needs exactly one active price in the same currency, and the buyer can add a quantity of one. If you create Checkout Sessions in code, optional items let you offer up to 10 add-ons per session. Either way, Stripe tells you to retrieve the session's line items when you fulfil the order; skip that step and the add-on is paid for but never delivered. On ThriveCart, you enable the bump in the product's settings and style it in the checkout editor, where the help guide shows a default pre-ticked setting; leave it unticked. We could not find a native order bump in Lemon Squeezy's checkout documentation.
Write the copy (examples below) and keep it short. One headline, one or two sentences, the price and the words "one-time".
Record a baseline, then switch it on. Note your checkout completion rate, average first order and refund rate for the four weeks before launch, so you have something to compare against.
Review after two months. Keep it, change the add-on or remove it, using the rules in the next sections.
Example copy for the bump
For a membership about running a small business: "Add the Week One template pack ($29, one-time). The 12 spreadsheets and docs our members ask for most in their first week, ready to copy into your own drive."
For an event ticket: "Add last month's workshop recording ($19, one-time). Watch the session this one builds on before the day, so you start with the basics already covered."
For a coaching membership: "Add a 30-minute starter call ($39, one-time). We'll set your first three goals together. You'll get a booking link straight after checkout."
Each one names what the buyer gets, why it helps with the thing they are already buying, and the price with the words "one-time". None of them uses urgency or a countdown, and none needs one.
Metrics to watch
Watch the take rate first: bumps bought divided by completed checkouts. Then check the main checkout completion rate against your baseline, because a bump that earns $580 a month but quietly costs you even a few memberships, and every renewal those members would have paid, may not be worth keeping. Watch the refund rate on the add-on separately from the main product, since a high one tells you buyers felt misled. Track average first order and, if you can, whether people actually open the templates or watch the recording. Circle's payments analytics has an Upsells tab showing checkout revenue lift, conversions, declines and abandons; check whether your bump appears there, and if not, count bump line items from your payment records.
Use a simple decision rule. Keep the bump if completion holds steady and add-on refunds stay low; change the add-on if the take rate is under about 3% after two months (our threshold, not an industry one); and remove it straight away if completion drops in a way you can see across both months.
Pitfalls
Pre-ticked boxes come first. Some tools let you tick the bump by default, which quietly adds money to the order unless the buyer notices and unticks it. In the EU, Article 22 of the Consumer Rights Directive requires a trader to get a consumer's "express consent" to any extra payment, and says that where consent was inferred "by using default options which the consumer is required to reject", the consumer is entitled to a refund. Even where the law is looser, a pre-ticked bump is a poor way to begin a membership.
Refunds come next. Decide in advance whether someone who refunds the main purchase also gets the add-on refunded, and say so in your terms. Keep refunds simple and quick; a buyer who feels tricked at checkout is more likely to cancel the membership too, a problem we covered in our piece on the reason-matched cancel flow.
Clutter comes third. Circle allows up to three bumps per paywall, ThriveCart up to six per checkout on its Pro+ plan, and Stripe's optional items up to ten per session. That a tool allows six does not mean your buyer wants to read six offers next to the pay button. Start with one.
Finally, watch the strikethrough price. Circle lets you show one, and it is honest only if the add-on really sells at the higher price elsewhere. A made-up "was" price costs you trust and, in many places, breaks consumer law on misleading pricing.
Variations
Pair the bump with an offer after payment: a small add-on at checkout, then a larger one (an annual plan or a premium tier) on the post-purchase page Circle added last month. The bigger offer suits a later moment better, the same thinking behind our 30-day upsell window. You can also target bumps at returning buyers; ThriveCart can show a bump only to customers who have bought a chosen product before, though it pre-ticks the bump for them, so check that setting too. And for buyers whose needs change after they join, an offer timed to that change will usually do better than anything at checkout, as we covered in the need-shift upsell.
If you run Circle, the feature should reach your account by the end of the month. Spend the time before then writing down what your new members ask for in their first week, because the best add-on is usually already on that list.

